Skip to content
SEO

How to Find (and Replicate) Competitor Backlinks

How to dig into a competitor's backlinks, find the sites that link to them but not you, and decide which are worth chasing.

The Press Parrot team7 min read

The sites beating you have already done half your research for you. You just have to go and look.

There's something quite satisfying about this one. Instead of guessing where your links should come from, you go and look at where the sites above you got theirs. Some of those sites will happily link to you as well. Some will take a bit of persuading. And a handful are best left alone entirely, but we'll get to those.

You don't need deep pockets for this, or years in SEO. A backlink tool, a spare hour and somewhere to dump a list will do it. Below is how we'd tackle it, start to finish, including the bit most guides skip, which is what to actually do with the list once you've got it.

Who's really beating you?

You'd think everyone knows who their competitors are. In search, they often don't. Your business competitors and your search competitors are often completely different lists.

Take a small online bike shop. In the real world it's competing with the other bike shop in town. In Google, the pages ranking for "best road bikes under £1,000" might be a cycling magazine, a review site, a big retailer and a Reddit thread. The shop down the road isn't nicking your traffic. That lot are.

Which is why we'd always begin with a search rather than a company name. Type in the handful of terms that matter most to you and jot down whoever keeps popping up on page one. Three to five sites is plenty. If one result is only there because it's Wikipedia or Amazon, skip it, since you won't be replicating their profile any time soon.

It helps to pick competitors that are roughly your size, or a step ahead. Studying a site with a hundred times your authority is interesting, but it won't tell you much about what you can realistically get. The ones just above you are where the useful links tend to be, and they're also the best guide when you're working out how many backlinks you need to catch up.

Pulling their backlinks

Ahrefs and Semrush are the two tools most people use for this, and either is fine. If you don't want to pay yet, both offer a free checker that shows a limited sample of a site's links, which is enough to get a feel for things before committing.

Here's roughly how we'd go about it.

  1. Put the competitor's ranking page into the tool, not just their homepage. You want the links pointing at the page that's beating yours.
  2. Switch the view to referring domains rather than individual backlinks. One site linking to them forty times is still just one site.
  3. Sort by domain rating if you like, so the bigger sites float up, though take it with a pinch of salt. We've seen DR 30 hobby blogs with loyal readers do more for a page than DR 70 sites with tumbleweed traffic, and the metrics worth looking at stretch a long way past that single score.
  4. Export the list. You'll be filtering and tagging it later, and that's miserable to do inside the tool.

Then do the same for the homepage or the whole domain. Plenty of sites rank on the strength of their overall authority rather than links to one page, and you'll miss that if you only look at the page level.

Running a link gap

This is where it gets genuinely useful.

A link gap (Ahrefs calls its version Link Intersect, Semrush calls it Backlink Gap) takes several competitors and shows you the sites linking to two or more of them but not to you. Those are your warmest leads by a mile. If a site has already linked to three of your rivals, it's clearly comfortable covering your topic, and there's a decent chance it'll link to you too.

Pop in your own domain plus three or four competitors and set it to show sites linking to at least two of them. Most of the time you'll get a list that's short enough to actually work through.

Go through it with a cup of tea and look at each site properly. Some will be publishers that sell placements, and it's worth checking whether any of them already turn up among the guest posts on Press Parrot, since that saves you the back-and-forth of pitching. Others will be resource pages, news sites, industry directories or forums. Each of those needs a different approach, which is what the next bit's about.

What can you actually replicate?

Not every link on a competitor's profile is up for grabs. Once you've got your list, tag each one by type, because that tells you straight away how (or whether) to go after it.

What you find

What it usually is

How you'd get one too

An article written for their brand on someone else's blog

A guest post

Approach the same site with a different angle, and make sure it's one the editor will actually approve

A link added to an older, established article

A niche edit

Ask about a similar placement on a related article, as it's often quicker than a fresh guest post when the right context already exists

A mention in a news story or trade piece

Digital PR coverage

Find a story or data angle of your own, which tends to work best alongside placed links

A list of useful tools or resources

A resource page

Email the owner if you've got something that genuinely belongs on it

A listing in an industry or local directory

A directory or citation

Usually just a matter of signing up, if the directory's legitimate

A forum post or comment

User-generated content

Take part properly. Dropping links tends to get them deleted

Thousands of links from one odd-looking site

A sitewide or spam link

Leave it alone

Guest posts, niche edits and resource pages tend to be the most repeatable. PR coverage is harder to copy like-for-like, because it was tied to a particular story at a particular moment, but it does show you which journalists and outlets cover your space.

A quick worked example

Let's go back to our made-up bike shop, Spokehouse, which is stuck on page two for "best road bikes under £1,000". Three sites sit above it: a cycling blog, a review site and a mid-sized retailer.

A link gap across those three turns up 46 sites linking to at least two of them but not to Spokehouse. Tagged by type, they break down something like this:

Type

Sites

Worth chasing?

Guest posts on cycling and fitness blogs

14

Yes, the main target

Niche edits on established cycling articles

9

Yes

Resource and "best tools" pages

6

Yes, via outreach

News and magazine coverage

7

Not directly, but noted for PR later

Directories

4

Two look legitimate

Spammy or sitewide links

6

No

That's roughly 30 realistic targets out of 46, which is a much better starting point than a blank page. The 14 guest post sites are the obvious place to begin, since every one of them has already said yes to the topic three times over.

(All of those numbers are invented for the example, but the shape is pretty typical. Most link gaps end up with a solid core of placeable sites and a tail of stuff you'll ignore.)

What not to copy

Replicating a competitor's links doesn't mean replicating everything they've done. Some of what you'll find is best admired from a distance.

If you spot hundreds of links from sites with no real content, no traffic and suspiciously similar layouts, that's probably a private blog network. Copying it is a fast way to inherit their risk. The same goes for obvious link farms and sites that link out to anyone for a fiver.

Their anchors are another thing to leave alone. If a competitor's profile is stuffed with the same exact-match phrase, that's not a template, it's a warning. You'll want your own mix, and the rough split we use for planning anchor text is a safer place to start than whatever they happened to do.

And don't assume their links are why they rank. Sometimes a competitor sits above you because their content is simply better, or their site's been around ten years longer. It's always worth reading their page with an honest eye before you spend money trying to out-link it.

Turning the list into a plan

A spreadsheet of 30 sites is nice to have, but it won't rank anything on its own. This is how we'd turn it into work.

  1. Rank the targets. Sites linking to three competitors go above sites linking to two, and relevant sites with real traffic go above everything else.
  2. Split them by approach. Placements you can buy, outreach you'll need to do yourself, and PR ideas for later.
  3. Price up the placements. Search for the sites on the Press Parrot marketplace, and where they're not listed, look for similar sites in the same niche that are.
  4. Spread it out over a few months. Ten links landing the same week looks odd, and spacing them out also lets you see what's working before you spend the rest.
  5. Re-run the gap every quarter or so. Competitors keep building, and new sites will turn up that weren't there the first time.

If it helps to see the whole thing laid out, you can map the order and budget in our free link building planner before committing to anything. Most people find the first round of a link gap gives them two or three months of work, which is a pretty good return on an hour's digging.

See what a placement actually costs

Every listing carries its domain rating, organic traffic, referring domains, country and price before you commit to anything. Filter to the publishers that fit the campaign you have just read about.

  • Domain Rating
  • Organic Traffic
  • Referring Domains
  • Price
Unlock the Marketplace

Create a free account to browse publishers and pricing.

Marketplace Preview

Create an account to view all websites

An illustration of the marketplace table. Website names are not shown to signed-out visitors.
WebsiteDRTrafficPrice
•••••••.comTechnology · Guest Post100176.0M$200-300
••••••••.comUncategorised · Guest Post900$100-200
•••••••••.comTechnology · Guest Post9020K$100-200
•••••••.comUncategorised · Niche Edit90100K$1300-1400
••••••••.deUncategorised · Guest Post900$100-200
•••••••••.deUncategorised · Guest Post900$100-200

Frequently asked questions

Can I see a competitor's backlinks for free?
Partly. Ahrefs and Semrush both have free checkers that show a sample of a site's links, which is fine for a quick look. For a proper link gap you'll need a paid plan, though most have a cheap trial.
How many competitors should I analyze?
Three to five is plenty. Fewer and the gap is too thin; more and the list gets unwieldy without adding much.
Is it OK to copy a competitor's backlinks?
Yes, in the sense of getting links from the same sites. Nobody owns a publisher. What you shouldn't copy is anything spammy, or their anchor text if it looks over-optimised.
Why do my competitors rank with fewer links than me?
Usually better content, a stronger domain overall, or links from more relevant sites. Link count on its own rarely tells the whole story.
How often should I check competitor backlinks?
Every three months or so is enough for most sites. In fast-moving niches, monthly isn't overkill.

Put it into practice

Create a free account and search thousands of vetted publishers in a few minutes.